[HUMAYRA]

We all know that theres all types of fish. What i am asking is that which one is haalal.

thanks

[MOLAAKEEL]

ALL FISHES ARE HALAL Akeel

[hassaanhashmi]

ALL ANIMALS OF THE SEA, ARE HALAAL, ALIVE OR DEAD

[hassaanhashmi]

ALL ANIMALS OF THE SEA, ARE HALAAL, ALIVE OR DEAD

[Abu-Feizah]

salaams
 

I believe that all fish are alive - not all that inhabits the sea is a fish - I am unsure but I think I heard from Syed Zahid Hussain Shah Saib once that only fish is permissible - other things may be haraam / makroo depending on the individual creature. for example there is a difference of opinion amongst the scholars with ref to prawns - some consider them halal whilst others choose to define prawns as not fish and therefore markroo.

Allah knows best.

wasalaam

[Mohammed-Haleem]

All Fishes are halal Why? beacuse by the time you would pull them out put a knife on the neck they would have been left the earth!

Depeding onthe kind of fish, it is halal.

There is this incident of Hazoor Paak Once A Sahbi brought fish, they tried cooking it but it wouldnt cook, so Sahibi left it for few days to cook but it still woudnt cook, So the Sahbi took it to Hazoor Paak an explained the situwation so Hazoor Paak lets ask the fish, so the fish replied " i was in my lake swiming until i heard this neice sweet voice reciting the durood paak (the fish read it out) and said this has gone into my heart and i wont cook coz it is in my heart" it was later known the reciter was Hazoor Paak .

Yanabi.com 4 Zindagi

يا نبى ۴ زندگى


محمدحليم نقشبندى صديقى

[MOLAAKEEL]

subhanallah
AKEEL

[Bas]

Has there ever been a ruling on whales?

It seems to take along time to kill them and there are mammals not fish.

[abdulrahim]

u juss being daft ofcourse fishes are halal

[nameless]

does any one know if its halal to eat a shark kabab. i had one during my university life it tased okish but at the time i thought it was ok. but can anyone clarify this with facts rather than opinions.  allah hafiz

[Bas]

Thank you for the information.

[hb014g4573]

is octopus haram?

[Mohammed-Haleem]

QUOTEOriginally posted by: IFTIKHAR HUSSAIN is octopus haram?

Ocutopus is not fish, but some chinse do eat them (Yuck).

Yanabi.com 4 Zindagi

يا نبى ۴ زندگى


محمدحليم نقشبندى صديقى

[Dua610]

just say allah knows best..........

[Dua610]

octopus iz halal iv aten it its yummy

[Saghe-dargaahe-Jilani]

Brother I have heard that Prawns and Crabs are Makrooh not Haraam!

P.S I dont eat any sea food but I have seen many people eating Prawns and Crabs and they are Sunni's!

Esp If you go to Kokan Madras and Chennai in India they eat Prawns and Crabs!

[Rasheed]

Assalam O Alaikum

Creature from water, only fresh fish from sea or river is Halal for Hanafi. But the same Halal fish became Haram if it is from cultivated farms where if the fish feed is made of pork bone meals or non-zabiha beef bone meal. This is true for cultivated Salmon, Catfish because there are many fish cultivated forms in USA and Europe. So before buying fish, please buy only fresh fish not cultivated fish.

Regarding fish at restuarants or fast food restuarants, do not order fried fish because who knows what is in coating used for fried fish, they can add Haram whey, Haram color and Haram flavor including beer flavor made with real beer. Even if you do not eat beer batter fish, your Halal fish is contaminated with beer batter fish because they use the same frying oil for all fish including beer batter fish, so your Halal fish became Haram. Red Lobster restaurants in USA/Canada uses same frying oil for beer batter fish and non beer batter fish. Only Broiled or Grilled fish with 100% butter should be order. Stay away from any sauces for broiled or grilled fish.

Syed Rasheeduddin Ahmed

[sabina-khayam]

Aslamwalaikum

correct me if I am wrong, but i was told if you eat anything that can breath in and out of water it is haram.

so crabs would be haram?

[muslimdk]

i've heard both halal and haram about octopus... can somebody please ask Mufakkar-e-Islam about this? or provide some evidences from hanafi fiqh works, or Alahadrat's fatwa etc.

Jazakallah