[Curious_Muslim]

Asalaamalaykum,
I came across a video on youtube
in this video it shows a vast amount of people dancing, there is tabla music and a qawal singing, the Qawal himself quotes the Shaman (Noori Bori wali Sarkar) he states something that i do not want to repeat, it can be found in the video. What i would like to know is what is the origins of this practice and how it is wrong, i myself from my basic knowledge can see there is a lot wrong.

Also there are more videos, one of Badshah Noori Shah and another of "Baba Current wali Sarkar"

Badshah Noori:
http://www.youtube com/watch?v=vHVrDlmIkDM&feature=related

Baba Current Shah:
http://www.youtube com/watch?v=Fi6yA-gDR_8

Can someone clarify these videos for me, Jazakallah

[piara-madinah]

 Curious_Muslim, on 18 December 2011 - 02:31 AM, said:

Asalaamalaykum,
I came across a video on youtube
in this video it shows a vast amount of people dancing, there is tabla music and a qawal singing, the Qawal himself quotes the Shaman (Noori Bori wali Sarkar) he states something that i do not want to repeat, it can be found in the video. What i would like to know is what is the origins of this practice and how it is wrong, i myself from my basic knowledge can see there is a lot wrong.

Also there are more videos, one of Badshah Noori Shah and another of "Baba Current wali Sarkar"

Badshah Noori:
http://www.youtube com/watch?v=vHVrDlmIkDM&feature=related

Baba Current Shah:
http://www.youtube com/watch?v=Fi6yA-gDR_8

Can someone clarify these videos for me, Jazakallah

This is not real must be someone add that in it or add all because how can it possible if the qawaal saying them words live on speakers, people keep dancing they will beat him with shoes if he try them words live on speakers on any dargah or mazaar.

[hamzaahmad123]

Sheikh Asrar Rashid on False Pirs.

[Curious_Muslim]

 piara-madinah, on 18 December 2011 - 06:27 PM, said:

This is not real must be someone add that in it or add all because how can it possible if the qawaal saying them words live on speakers, people keep dancing they will beat him with shoes if he try them words live on speakers on any dargah or mazaar.

This i real brother, I have spoken to a follower of this 'Pir' and he stand firmly by the 'Teaching' of Noori Bori wali Sarkar and the derogatory language used by the so called Pir was quoted to me also, I know this practice is wrong, but what is the justification of it's wrongness?

[tazhameed]

someone asked the very same question on ummah channel



People who have control in Bari Imam and Lal Shabaz Qalandar Darbar are Shia - Syed Irfan Shah

http://youtu.be/UYLrgvSLWpE

[piara-madinah]

 tazhameed, on 20 December 2011 - 10:13 PM, said:

someone asked the very same question on ummah channel



People who have control in Bari Imam and Lal Shabaz Qalandar Darbar are Shia - Syed Irfan Shah

http://youtu.be/UYLrgvSLWpE

I think bari imam under oqaaf department are they shia.