Originally posted by: Naseer Ameen
'Pir Mehr Ali Shah praises the efforts of Shah Ismail Shaheed'He has got an 'alim' saying everything with Pir Mehr Ali Shah Radi Allahu Ta'ala Anho's book in front of them open on the pageAnd the other videos with Sayyidi Ala Hazrat Radi Allahu Ta'ala Anho's books infront of them, showing the refered pages, it is very confusing.
Brother, Pir sahib (Radi Allah Anhu) is not praising his aqeeda or his works on islam(astaghfirullah),but rather the armed uprising against the british government of the time, which was a jihad.
All Pir sahib(Radi Allah Anhu) is saying Allah reward each group for their efforts in taking part in the fight against the british.
This deo is twisting things by suggesting that if he (ismail dehlvi)was a gustaak e rasool (SalAllaho Alahi WaAlehi Wasalam) then why would Pir sahib say the above?
Which is clearly clutching at straws and a very desparate attempt to clear their wrongs.Tell them that the contentious issue is aqaid and there disrespectful/kufria statements in the books of a few of their top scholars, not on the collective war effort or jihad against the british raj,it was on these that Ala Hadrat (Radi Allah Anhu) and other scholars gave a fatwa against them.
Dont forget Ala Hadrat(Radi Allah Anhu) also refrained from passing fatwa of kufr on ismail dehlvi(although his shaikh hadrat Khairabadi)did pass a fatwa on him.
Why do they not post the rest of fatwa mehria which deals with hazar nazir,ilme ghaib,milad and other sunni beliefs that are contained within it?
Tell them to bring proof where Hadrat Pir Syed Mehr Ai Shah(Radi Allah Anhu) went against Ala Hadrat(Radi Allah Anhu) on these particular issue.
They wont find any i guarantee you!